Is Mosaic's "The Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington" Worth Purchasing? A Comprehensive Review
Duke Ellington's vast and influential musical legacy continues to captivate audiences worldwide. For those seeking a definitive collection of his work during his Capitol Records period (1956-1962), Mosaic Records' box set, "The Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington," stands as a significant contender. But is it worth the investment? This comprehensive review delves into the merits and considerations surrounding this extensive release.
What Makes This Box Set Special?
This isn't just a compilation of Ellington's Capitol recordings; it's a meticulously curated and restored collection aiming for ultimate sonic fidelity. Mosaic is renowned for its commitment to archival quality, and this set reflects that dedication. The recordings have been remastered from the original tapes, resulting in a sound far superior to any previously released versions. The sheer volume of music included – encompassing both studio albums and previously unreleased material – makes it a treasure trove for Ellington enthusiasts.
Beyond the Music: What's Included?
The box set's value extends beyond the music itself. It typically includes extensive liner notes, providing historical context, session details, and insightful commentary on the recordings. This contextual information adds a layer of depth, enriching the listening experience and enhancing appreciation for Ellington's artistry. The packaging itself is often of high quality, reflecting the investment in the project.
H2: Is it Worth the Price? A Cost-Benefit Analysis
The price point for such a comprehensive box set is undoubtedly a significant factor. However, the cost-benefit analysis hinges on individual priorities. For serious Ellington collectors and aficionados, the unparalleled audio quality, unreleased material, and extensive liner notes likely justify the expense. The value proposition lies in the completeness and archival quality—this is not merely a collection of readily available albums.
H2: What are the alternatives?
Several alternative compilations of Duke Ellington's music exist, offering a range of price points and selections. Budget-conscious listeners might find satisfaction with more affordable compilations featuring highlights from his Capitol period. However, these alternatives will inevitably lack the completeness, audio quality, and historical depth offered by the Mosaic set. The choice depends on the level of detail and completeness desired.
H2: Are there any downsides?
The main downside, as mentioned, is the price. It's a significant investment that may be prohibitive for casual listeners. The sheer volume of music can also be overwhelming for those new to Ellington's work; it's a considerable commitment to explore such an extensive collection.
H2: What other recordings of Duke Ellington are worth listening to?
While the Capitol recordings are a significant period in Ellington's career, his discography is vast and spans several decades with different recording labels. Exploring recordings from his time with RCA Victor, Columbia, and other labels would reveal other facets of his genius and musical evolution. Each period offers distinct stylistic characteristics and collaborations.
Conclusion:
Mosaic's "The Complete Capitol Recordings of Duke Ellington" is not for the casual listener. It's a definitive statement for dedicated Ellington enthusiasts and serious collectors willing to invest in an unparalleled archival experience. The superior audio quality, unreleased material, and extensive liner notes offer immense value, but careful consideration of the price and the commitment required to delve into such an extensive body of work is crucial before purchasing. The ultimate decision depends on individual priorities and the depth of one's appreciation for Duke Ellington's musical genius.
